imaginary circus

Writer, fangirl, bon vivant. My interests are all over the map. I love good stories however they come packaged.

Liker of coffee and words. Occasionally cranky. tumblr elderly. I apologize in advance for my tags.

KyrieAnne and I are debating what Hogwarts House Anne would be in. She’s saying Slytherin. I said Ravenclaw, but I could see an argument for Gryffindor.

Though I also think it depends on when she attends and who her family is. A Muggleborn in 1870s Hogwarts would have been pretty sad in Slytherin, I think.

I’m going with Muggleborn orphan from Derbyshire (because that’s what a history search on last name Shirley told me.) Same class as Dumbledore. They were both fetching red-heads. Ravenclaw. Head girl.

What say you?

  1. mmebookworm reblogged this from kyrieanne and added:
    As much as an argument could be made for any house, I see so many parallels with Luna Lovegood that I can’t help but...
  2. addleheadedfemale answered: I have so many feelings about Slytherin. I think JKR did a disservice to her world building by not letting ANY Slytherins fight for Hogwarts
  3. fievelthefruitcakemouse reblogged this from imaginarycircus and added:
    Ravenclaw. “where those of wit and learning…”
  4. goldenfirefly96 reblogged this from imaginarycircus and added:
    Look at this, my favourite topic ever. Like, we’ve discussed this three months ago too… As for me, I still can’t really...
  5. ccanadensis reblogged this from kyrieanne and added:
    I think I’m convinced - Anne is Slytherin. She is quite wily.
  6. anonsally answered: I did a bit of a poll about Sorting Anne a while back. I ended up thinking Hufflepuff.
  7. sullenaquarian reblogged this from kyrieanne and added:
    I really enjoyed reading this. Wish we could have seen more well-rounded Slytherins in the books. Gilbert is a...
  8. lysilly reblogged this from imaginarycircus
  9. neither-saint-nor-sinner said: Yo I love Anne Shirley and I’d like nothing better than to have her in my house, but she’s no Slytherin. I’d go with ‘claw, of the Luna Lovegood persuasion.
  10. imaginarycircus reblogged this from kyrieanne and added:
    This is great. I love her. I knew she had reasons. :D It’s impossible for us to say if Anne would be a Muggleborn or...
  11. actressandfangirl reblogged this from kyrieanne and added:
    I do get some of your arguments for Slytherin. It just doesn’t seem right though. Okay, so we have Anne, full of whimsy,...
  12. carrieiam reblogged this from kyrieanne
  13. gingerfangirl77 reblogged this from kyrieanne
  14. kyrieanne reblogged this from imaginarycircus and added:
    I’m not going to defend this theory to death; I agree Anne Shirley could be sorted into a lot of different houses and...
  15. scarletwinterraven said: Plus she’s always asking questions. I mean, how perfect is that for the house that needs to answer a question to get in their common room?
  16. yesknopemaybe answered: I feel very strongly that she’s not a slytherin. I could see her equally in gryf or ravenclaw. She gets a little more hufflepuff as an adult
  17. imagineagreatadventure answered: Gryffindor or Ravenclaw would be my guess. I think it’d almost depend on her mood that day though.
  18. lulabo answered: Ravenclaw—her inquisitiveness, her curiosity. I think. Now I want to take a sorting quiz pretending I’m Anne.
  19. belovedcreation answered: I say Ravenclaw, but I am totally a ‘Claw so I’m biased. AND DAMN SHE HAS A HUGE IMAGINATION!
  20. cribblesticks answered: Yeah I dunno, I think I used to have a strong opinion about this once upon a time but now I don’t know. I lean towards R but…